The relationship between healthcare providers and insurance payers is at a breaking point. What was once a shared mission to deliver quality patient care has devolved into a maze of denials, delays, and frustration. As denial rates hit historic highs, the impact is felt across the board: providers are overwhelmed, patients are underserved, and payers are reporting record profits.
This isn’t just administrative friction — it’s a healthcare crisis.
What’s Changed?
Over the past few years, the payer-provider dynamic has dramatically shifted. Here are some troubling trends:
-
80% of denials are part of what appears to be a systematic effort by payers to reduce payouts.
-
Some insurers now require full patient medical records for claims above a certain amount — even when that level of documentation isn’t clinically relevant.
-
Providers often face impossible choices when insurers deny care deemed medically necessary:
-
Spend time and money on appeals and arbitration
-
Accept a fraction of the reimbursement
- Or forgo payment entirely
-
Who should decide what’s medically necessary — the clinician or the insurance company?
Denials Are Climbing
-
76% increase in prior authorization denials
What’s intended to prevent fraud or excessive costs ends up delaying or denying legitimate care and payments. -
75% of providers cite a lack of payer accountability
Even when claims are eventually paid, the process is slow, opaque, and unnecessarily burdensome. -
61% report increased difficulty in contract negotiations
Some Medicare Advantage plans pay less than Medicare itself. -
56% of providers say payment rules lack transparency
Each payer uses its own playbook — constantly changing rules, unclear criteria, and hidden policies. -
54% note the growing use of bots and AI to issue denials
Automated decisions are faster — but further removed from clinical judgment and harder to dispute.
What This Means for Providers
Hospitals and practices are spending millions each year just trying to collect what they’re owed. Denials force providers to hire third-party services or invest in costly tech to compete in a high-stakes game of claims recovery. Instead of focusing on patient care, healthcare teams are tied up in red tape.
What This Means for Patients
Patients, who are the customers of both payers and providers, are stuck in the middle — and paying the price:
-
Surprise bills and long-delayed statements
-
Confusion about coverage, costs, and responsibilities
-
Rescheduled or canceled procedures due to authorization delays
-
Loss of trust in the healthcare system
-
Delayed care or skipped treatment altogether
Patients who are already in pain or managing chronic conditions now face new barriers to getting timely, effective care.
It’s Time to Shift the Balance
The data is clear: the current system prioritizes payer profits over patient outcomes and provider sustainability. It doesn’t have to be this way.
We must:
-
Return clinical decision-making to clinicians
-
Demand transparency from payers on rules, policies, and AI-driven decisions
-
Push for policy reforms that center the patient-provider relationship
Healthcare should be about healing — not fighting through red tape. It’s time to rebuild trust, restore balance, and reimagine a system that works for everyone.
To schedule a time to discuss how Frost-Arnett can help you with your denials, please fill out the form below.
Request A Proposal